American job creators struggling to find qualified applicants for basic jobs

From the Wall Street Journal.


More than 600,000 jobs in manufacturing went unfilled in 2011 due to a skills shortage, according to a survey conducted by the consultancy Deloitte.

The problem seems soluble: Equip workers with the skills they need to match them with employers who are hiring. That explains the emphasis that policy makers of both parties place on science, technology, engineering and math degrees—it is such a mantra that they’re known by shorthand as STEM degrees.

American manufacturing has become more advanced, we’re told, and requires computer aptitude, intricate problem solving, and greater dexterity with complex tasks. Surely if Americans were getting STEM education, they would have the skills they need to get jobs in our modern, high-tech economy.

But considerable evidence suggests that many employers would be happy just to find job applicants who have the sort of “soft” skills that used to be almost taken for granted. In the Manpower Group’s 2012 Talent Shortage Survey, nearly 20% of employers cited a lack of soft skills as a key reason they couldn’t hire needed employees. “Interpersonal skills and enthusiasm/motivation” were among the most commonly identified soft skills that employers found lacking.

Employers also mention a lack of elementary command of the English language. A survey in April of human-resources professionals conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management and the AARP compared the skills gap between older workers who were nearing retirement and younger workers coming into the labor pool. More than half of the organizations surveyed reported that simple grammar and spelling were the top “basic” skills among older workers that are not readily present among younger workers.

The SHRM/AARP survey also found that “professionalism” or “work ethic” is the top “applied” skill that younger workers lack. This finding is bolstered by the Empire Manufacturing Survey for April, published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. It said that manufacturers were finding it harder to find punctual, reliable workers today than in 2007, “an interesting result given that New York State’s unemployment rate was more than 4 percentage points lower in early 2007 than in early 2012.”

Stuart Schneiderman blames the focus on equality and self-esteem over competition and achievement:

The American school system has failed America’s students. It has especially failed to teach the skills required to do the kinds of high tech jobs that are increasingly available.
American children are deficient in science, technology, engineering and math, in what are now known as the STEM subjects.
It should surprise no one. A pedagogical policy promoting self-esteem over achievement must diminish the best students in order to make the worst students feel good about themselves. The result: a large cohort of undereducated underachievers who are proud of their incompetence.
In STEM subjects there are right and wrong answers. When these subjects are taught correctly, you will find that some children are markedly better than others.
Children improve because they emulate their betters. They strive to get better because they want to be as good as someone else.
If the best students are rewarded other children will want to emulate them. If the best students are demeaned no one will want to emulate them.
If you refuse to call on them in class, if you refuse to hold them up as exemplary, if you turn math exercises into storytelling and feeling sharing you are going to drag everyone down.
If you say that no one is better than anyone else, you are saying that no child should strive for greater achievements.

Stuart didn’t say it, so I will. It’s important to be careful about handing your children off to any school, especially the feminized public school system. The public school system from administration to the classroom is not welcoming to values like competition and individual achievement – which are more often (but not exclusively) associated with men. Unfortunately, there just aren’t many men in public school classrooms. Public schools favor security and equality of outcomes. These goals are best achieved by growing government to minimize individual achievement and to maximize the “safety net”, so that individual striving doesn’t matter. Another goal of the public school system is to increase the amount of money they are paid. They want higher taxes and more government spending, so that they are paid more. Their job is not to get your children skills so they can be independent of government. They want more government. They want more security. They want less personal responsibility. They want less individual achievement.

I think that teachers should have to work in a field related to what they want to teach in for at least 5 years before being admitted to teacher’s college. That requirement alone would improve education drastically.

2 thoughts on “American job creators struggling to find qualified applicants for basic jobs”

  1. While I have not doubt that many if not most of American schools are failing our students because they don’t want to hurt their feelings and tell them they’re doing something wrong, there’s a second side to this coin you’re not discussing. That is, the skills desired to pay ratio. My one brother has often worked in a machine shop – a CNC operator. recently he applied for another job – what did they want? 10 years experience, a couple of certs, and a bachelors degree, preferrably mechanical eng, math, or CS. What was the pay/benefits? $7.75 to start, 1 week vacation, no medical for the first five years (odd there) and nothing else. That is why they can’t fill those 600,000 factory jobs. hitting a couple buttons on a machine doesn’t require much in the way of brains or communication skills and it definitely doesn’t require a college degree. Now, if you’re gonna make those requirements, you’re not gonna find a single person who can afford to have filled those requirements, namely getting a college degree and still afford to live in the US.

    I have no doubt this is just a ploy to attempt to get the US government to open the H1B visa flood gates.

    (the jobs I’m speaking of were applied for by friends and family in the Rochester, NY area – cheaper than most to live in, but not livable on $8/hr with no benefits).


  2. This ties in with a recent article on a South African news website – see However, this item revolves around the recent miners’ strikes. I believe that our education system is producing youngsters who are qualified to do nothing, and most of them cannot afford tertiary education, so they end in dead-end jobs earning a pittance. There is a major skills shortage across the board, from skilled labour / artisans, through to highly technical skills. Not everyone is academically inclined, so the push in that direction resulted in a huge failure and drop-out rate, compounded by the ill-advised and poorly implemented OBE system that was foisted on schools and which is inclined to “pass one, pass all” while down-playing academic excellence as “disadvantaging” those who don’t excel. The school system here is for the most part dysfunctional – only former “white” schools have maintained standards (and then not all of them – it’s been a battle) and the shining stars amongst the former “black” schools are rare. Eighteen years down the line, and our politically correct, socialist government has produced a bunch of socialist and culture-of-entitlement minded opinionated ignoramuses and ne’er-do-wells. Those who have done well, attended former “white” schools, or private schools. Interestingly enough, most ANC politicians’ children attend these, not the still disadvantaged schools.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s