New study: Asian students outperform whites because they work harder

This is from Science, one of the top peer-reviewed journals. (H/T Nancy P.)

Excerpt:

When it comes to academic achievement, Asian-Americans outclass every other ethnic group, with more than half over age 25 holding a bachelor’s degree—well above the national average of 28%. To find what gives Asian-Americans a leg up, a team of sociologists scoured two long-term surveys covering more than 5000 U.S. Asian and white students. After crunching test scores, GPAs, teacher evaluations, and social factors such as immigration status, the team reports a simple explanation online today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesAsian-American students work harder.

The team found that students from all Asian ethnic groups put greater importance on effort than on natural ability. This outlook, the team argues, causes students to respond to challenges by trying harder and has a greater impact on Asian-Americans’ academic achievement than does cognitive ability or socioeconomic status. However, the team says Asian-American students reported lower self-esteem, more conflict with their parents, and less time spent with friends compared with their white peers. The team suspects the high academic expectations or their “outsider” status in American society could be to blame.

You know, a lot of people blame racism when some minorities underperform at school. But if that were so, then why aren’t Asians affected? The answer is that underperforming at school has nothing to do with race or racism. It’s all about strong marriages, strong families and hard work. Discipline.

The soft bigotry of low expectations

In other news, judges at a debate tournament gave the first prize to two black students who used vulgar language in their speeches.

The College Fix reports.

Excerpt:

This year’s debate question centered on the Presidential War Powers. But Towson, reports The Atlantic, took a different approach:

On March 24, 2014, at the Cross Examination Debate Association (CEDA) Championships at Indiana University, two Towson University students, Ameena Ruffin and Korey Johnson, became the first African-American women to win a national college debate tournament, for which the resolution asked whether the U.S. president’s war powers should be restricted.

Rather than address the resolution straight on, Ruffin and Johnson, along with other teams of African-Americans, attacked its premise. The more pressing issue, they argued, is how the U.S. government is at war with poor black communities.

And how did Towson plead its case? Here’s a censored excerpt provided by Pundit Press:

They say the n*****s always already qu***, that’s exactly the point! It means the impact is that the that the is the impact term, uh, to the afraid, uh, the, that it is a case term to the affirmative because, we, uh, we’re saying that qu*** bodies are not able to survive the necessarily means of the body. Uh, uh, the n***** is not able to survive.

Perhaps I am missing the finer nuances of college debate, but assuming I understand cross-examination debate correctly, this form of incoherent chaos is unacceptable, unprofessional, and in many ways, nonsensical.

For the record, I’m not white. I’m writing about this as one of those overperforming brown-skinned people.

 

6 thoughts on “New study: Asian students outperform whites because they work harder”

  1. It’s harder and harder to play that race card the more ethnically diverse America is becoming. Dinesh D’Sousa said that his skin is as dark as the skin of Jesse Jackson, and yet D’Sousa does not think that he is at a disadvantage for it.

    Like

  2. This is true. At college, most of my friends are Asian (only one is Asian American though) and they do work hard. They put their work ahead of socialization. Most don’t go to parties and fool around. They also major in harder subjects that will give them better job opportunities when they graduate from college.

    Like

  3. “This outlook, the team argues, causes students to respond to challenges by trying harder and has a greater impact on Asian-Americans’ academic achievement than does cognitive ability or socioeconomic status. ”
    What is interesting about this is that it means that hard work and academic achievement can be conditioned and would also explain why African Americans and Hispanics do poorly. The public school system practically sets them up to fail.
    I agree, the best environment to raise successful children are strong, intact, and structured families.

    Like

  4. I might be willing to argue that white parents put more emphasis on socializing and “having fun” than working hard toward school and later-life success.

    Like

  5. Shocking!!

    Success requires work?

    You mean I don’t deserve success as a birthright?

    I’m sure there is a class action law suit here. Who do I sue for discriminating against me?

    Like

Leave a reply to Entitled1 Cancel reply