Is there a gay gene? Are gay people born that way?

Stanton L. Jones writes about what the research shows in First Things.

Excerpt:

Frank Bruni, in his essay “Genetic or Not, Gay Will Not Go Away“(New York Times, January 28, 2012), makes a broad point regarding which I am in complete agreement: Our societal, legal, and cultural debates will not be solved by science. But when you do cite the science, you ought to get it right.

[…]In support of the argument that at least sometimes sexual orientation is a condition of birth, Bruni describes how “One landmark study looked at gay men’s brothers and found that 52% of identical twin brothers were also gay.” This brief explanation both fails as a description of that 20+ year old study and fails to reflect the better research published since.

Bruni gets the number right; the 1990 landmark study by Bailey and Pillard reported a 52% “probandwise concordance” for homosexual orientation among genetically identical sibling groups, but this does not mean what Bruni says it means. A proband wise concordance is a technical calculation, one that in this case results from the following actual results: There were 41 genetically identical sibling groups (40 identical twin pairs and one triplet trio) and of these 41 groups, only in 14 of the groups did the genetically identical brothers match for sexual orientation; in the remaining 27 sets the identical twin brothers did not match.

But this 1990 study was actually based on a sample that was apparently distorted by volunteer bias and hence not representative of homosexual persons in general. Bailey’s own study of a decade later, and the recently published “gold standard” study by Långström et. al. of the Swedish Twin Registry, both found even lower matching among identical twins with much larger and more representative samples. Both studies reported about 10% matching (for Långström, 7 identical twin pairs matched with both identical brothers gay out of 71 total pairs of male identical twin pairs).

So in plain English, the best contemporary scientific findings are that when one identical twin brother is gay, the probabilities of the second twin being gay are approximately 10%. This suggests that the contribution of genetics to the determination of homosexual orientation is modest at best.

When forming your views on any controversial issue, it’s important to get your facts straight.

My previous post discusses what the peer-reviewed research shows about homosexuality.

4 thoughts on “Is there a gay gene? Are gay people born that way?”

  1. All that aside, doesn’t genetic predisposition seem irrelevant from a moral perspective? If I’m born with a genetic disposition for, say, gluttony or anger outbursts…that doesn’t mean I’m obliged to define myself by these behaviors. I have the moral responsibility, as a Christian, to resist them. And I’m not a “hater” for condemning these behaviors in others. Because that’s ultimately what this is about: behavior, not disposition.

    Like

  2. Matt, you are the first person that I have noticed to use my favorite argument. I would go on to say that just because someone may have tendencies toward any of the various sexual problems, from pedophilia to beastiality, being “born” that way, doesn’t mean that it is appropriate to act them out.

    Like

  3. Matt and J. Paul, I couldn’t agree more. Stanton’s post exposes an interesting dynamic that we see acted out everyday. That is if “scientific fact or cause” can jusitfy a behavior or choice, it must be okay. That may be the case for those with physical and mental disabilities but for those who have the capacity to make moral choices, it’s an excuse. In simple terms, it’s that “see I told you so” approach. The facts say “being gay” is genetic so it’s not my fault. See I told you so. The obvious problem here is that for about everything we say or do, we can probably find some sort of “scientific fact or cause” to support it. Now were back to the question of Is there one Truth or is Truth Relevant?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s