Can a Christian woman divorce her husband if she is really, really unhappy?

So, the topic for this post is whether it’s OK to get divorced.

I noticed a lot of people getting divorced these days in the church, and trying to justify why they are allowed to divorce and why they should be allowed to pursue remarriage. So I’m first going to quote from an article from Focus on the Family by Amy Tracy.

She writes:

God is very clear, however, that He hates divorce (Malachi 2:16). He also says, “So they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate” (Matthew 19:6). According to the New Testament, there are two justifications for divorce: infidelity (Matthew 5:32) and desertion (1 Corinthians 7:15).

Now, I had always taken the rule of Dr. Laura for this. She says that you can get divorced for adultery and abandonment (as above), but she allows allows for physical abuse and drug addiction. But it looks like the Bible is more strict than Dr. Laura, even.

Now with that Biblical standard in mind, take a look at this post about a woman who professes to be a Christian who is divorcing her husband for unhappiness, which I found on Sunshine Mary’s blog.

Look:

So how are we to understand women like Jenny Erickson, and the many other Christian women like her, who claim that despite thousands of years of Christian and Jewish tradition, despite the clear commands in Scripture not to separate from one’s husband, despite the commandments against adultery, nevertheless the Lord God Himself has made a special exemption just for her?  Because He wants her to be happy, so if she needs to be a faithless woman who breaks her vows and becomes an adulteress, then hey it’s all good?

[…]After secretly filing for divorce from her husband, Mrs. Erickson’s pastor caught wind of the situation and attempted to discuss it with her.  When she refused, the pastor went to her husband about the situation.  Mrs. Erickson has since railed against her soon-to-be ex-husband and her now ex-Pastor because they actually had the nerve to call what she was doing a sin – which, according to the Bible, is is.  Let’s read through a few quotes from Mrs. Erickson:

Thankfully, my faith in God is stronger than my fear of men, and I feel like I’m finally getting right with Him again after years of wandering in the wilderness.

[…]Here are a few more things that Mrs. Erickson claims:

It’s odd and strangely freeing to not know exactly where I’m going to be a year from now. I’ve always been the girl with The Plan. The Plan has changed every now and then, because hey, life requires adaptation, but right now there is No Plan other than love my girls like crazy, work hard enough to pay the bills, and rely totally and fully on God.  I’m sure His Plan is better than My Plan anyway.

and

I needed a time-out for my marriage — possibly a permanent one. But every person that tells me I’m going against God’s will by separating from my husband drives me further away from wanting to reconcile with him.

Details aren’t needed. Leif is the father of my amazing children, and I want nothing more than to be his friend again someday, regardless of what happens in our marriage. But things have been very broken between us for a very long time, and it took every ounce of courage I had to take the step that went against everything my religious culture told me but somehow I knew God was telling me was right.

and

To be told that this beautiful, wonderful thing I have learned exists in my soul, this thing that gives me the strength to flip my life over when nothing else has worked, this thing that has made me braver than I thought possible, and made me rely on God more than I ever have in my entire life … to be told that this is a perversion of His plan for me?

These points must confuse a lot of women because I have heard these rationalizations used by many Christian women who are leaving or have left their husbands.  Therefore, allow me to clear up the confusion that seems to be rampant (but it really isn’t confusion, it is willful disobedience), lest any of my sisters in Christ are considering following Mrs. Erickson’s example.

God’s plan for you will never include violating anything written in the Bible.

If you hear a voice whispering in your ear, Here’s the plan; what I want you to do is... and the plan includes going against clear commandments in God’s Word, then it is not God who is speaking to you.  God’s plan for your life, sister, never includes you filing for divorce.  Not ever, not under any circumstances, no matter what your husband has or has not done, no matter what you want, no matter what would make you happy.

So, I think we (men) need to be really careful with spousal candidates (women) who claim to be Christian – we need to make sure that they really are comfortable with being led and with the authority of the Bible to overrule their feelings. In fact, you can check to see if a person takes their faith seriously just by trying to lead them to take the Bible seriously. You just have to read the Bible and think about how to live it out in a marriage, and then talk to your spousal candidate about what you’ve discovered. You want to present to them your plans and your reasons for those plans, and explain what you need them to do in order to make the plan work. This is a great way to see if they know what marriage is really about and how they feel about what’s expected of them if they marry YOU.

11 thoughts on “Can a Christian woman divorce her husband if she is really, really unhappy?”

  1. “But things have been very broken between us for a very long time…” She is an observer and doesn’t see herself as an active participant. It’s like she’s saying “Something went wrong and I don’t know when or how, I just want to be happy again.” It’s almost a consumer mind-set. A person wants this sort of spouse and this sort of marriage until one day they don’t. Then it’s “I just want to be friends.” I expect that from those outside of the Church. But from my sisters in Christ, there needs to be an intervention. Makes me wonder if she was caught up in the “50 Shades” mentality?

    Like

  2. Just to split a few hairs, there are no examples in the bible where it is “good” or appropriate to divorce. The Matthew verse is often misquoted as saying the is an exception for adultery, but the text says:
    “But I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, makes her the victim of adultery”.
    It does NOT says it’s OK to divorce, but rather the point Jesus is making is that if the spouse is already committing adultery, then you are not causing them to commit adultery. If they are not committing adultery, then your divorcing them sends them into adultery.
    Likewise the Corinthians verse says stay with your spouse, unless they dump you. If they dump you, it’s hard to stay married – that’s on them at that point.

    Now, there is still grace for those who are divorced, adulterers, and all of us who have sinned. Let’s just not say that the divorce is acceptable.

    Like

    1. Agree. I have yet to see any Biblical passage that says it’s okay to initiate divorce. God says He hates divorce. I don’t think God thinks it’s okay to do what he hates.

      Like

  3. It’s also important to recognize that Jesus explained that the reason God allowed for divorce in certain situations was because their hearts were hard. It would appear that two hard-hearted people would have a difficult time remaining married, and would turn marriage into something like torture. What do you think brings more honor to God’s name?

    Like

    1. It’s a dilemma. I hope it never happens to me that I choose poorly. And I worry that I am not ready for it ever. I am so emotional and am easily rattled when things go wrong. Unless I know what I am doing.

      Like

  4. I never could understand people who wring their hands and wonder how they’re going to stay married. Um, it’s easy. If you don’t divorce, you’ll stay married. You don’t have to do something to stay married. Once you get married, marriage is the default. You have to actively do something to stop being married. If you don’t do that thing (and your spouse doesn’t either), you stay married. It’s really simple.

    Of course, staying happily married is much more difficult. But people seem to have this idea that if they aren’t happy, they just automatically get divorced, as if they have no choice in the matter. They act like filing divorce papers just happens to people. People can get divorced by their spouse and they have no choice in the matter (thanks to no-fault divorce). But if you’re the one who filed for divorce, it didn’t just happen to you. You chose to divorce. Don’t pretend you didn’t have a choice.

    Like

  5. WK, I hear you. I’m at the point now where I waffle between desiring a relationship leading to marriage and dreading the conflict it will take to get there. Life is messy.

    Like

  6. @Wintery Knight
    You didn’t state what you view is in the case of spousal abuse. Do you believe that a battered wife is forbidden to divorce her husband?

    Like

    1. Nicholas, I don’t know what WK would say to this. But I’ll throw my two cents in. In a situation like that you have two conflicting commands of God. One that you should not divorce and two that you have to be faithful with the gifts that God has given you, including his gift of life. So ultimately it depends on the situation. If the only thing you can do to protect yourself from your spouse killing you is getting a divorce then yes. Do that. Legally spouses have rights that can make it harder to stop them. There are sadly times in our lives like this where there isn’t really a non-sinful option. This is why we are thankful that Christ died for our sins. But you don’t want to take these hard situations and make too broad of a rule for it. E.g. I can divorce my wife because she yells at me. That counts as abuse. Which is absolutely something our sinful nature will do. Do everything to protect the abused person and save the marriage, but when it comes down to it protect the abused person first and foremost.

      Like

Leave a reply to mckenziebree Cancel reply