Pro-abortion vandals: destroying pro-life display was “free speech”

Unborn baby scheming catching vandals in a foot race
Unborn baby scheming about catching vandals in a foot race

I see that Neil Simpson linked to this Life Site News article in his latest round-up.

Excerpt:

A group of youths arrested and charged with vandalizing a Kentucky pro-life campus display said that destroying the display was an expression of their “right to free speech.”

Pro-life leaders of Northern Right to Life at Northern Kentucky University (NKU) say they first set up the display on Monday morning. It consisted of tiny onesies hanging on a line with red “X” taped onto every fourth outfit to symbolize a life lost to abortion. The display included a sign explaining its significance and citing the Guttmacher Institute.

But after the display was torn down twice within the first two days, members of the pro-life group began taking night shifts to watch for the vandals. On Friday morning around 1am, they say they spotted four young men beginning to cut down the line and throwing the clothing, which was to be donated to needy local children, in the trash.

[…]Both Piron and the Kentucky Post report that the three suspects police caught – Travis Black, Steven White and Montez Jenkins Copeland – have been charged with Criminal Mischief.

“Though the vandals don’t think they deserve to be faced with consequences, we at NRTL believe that it’s important for people to understand that they cannot just rip down a display simply because they disagree with its message,” said Piron.

A fourth suspect who had turned himself in, Kyle Pickett, agreed with pro-lifers that they had a right to display the clothing as free speech – but justified the vandalism as equally protected.

“Tearing it down was expressing our right to free speech,” he said, according to the Post.

I think that the pro-life movement would do well to buckle down and learn how to defend the pro-life view with arguments and evidence. Because if undecided people have to decide between persuasion and violence, persuasion is going to win every time.

I recommend taking a look at Neil’s round-up. There were several good stories in there, but I just chose one to link to.

9 thoughts on “Pro-abortion vandals: destroying pro-life display was “free speech””

  1. Seriously…. if those pro life people had the right to put it up those boys had the right to take it down… freedom of speech goes both way. This is so sickening.

    Like

    1. ???

      Laura, one is free speech, the other is destruction of property and the prevention of free speech. Two very different things. If they *really* wanted to exercise their free speech, they could have put up a counter-display.

      Like

    2. Freedom of speech does not mean freedom to destroy other people’s property. Otherwise, people such as those in Occupy Wall Street could decide that a wealthy person didn’t deserve the house they live in, burn it down, and then claim that committing arson was actually them making a political statement.

      The display that was put up was the property of the Northern Right to Life at Northern Kentucky University. Those who disagree with the Pro-Lifers can hold counter demonstrations to air their disagrement. However, they do not have the right to destroy the property of the Pro-Lifers because of their disagreement.

      Like

      1. Burning it down would be a political statement. Revolution is a political statement.

        You seem to be saying that ‘political statements’ are only those that abide by the law … a dangerous and naive way of looking at things.

        Freedom of speech on the other hand is something mandated by your constitution and another thing altogether.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s