“Unbelievable”, is a show broadcast every Saturday in the UK. Every week, they feature a debate between a Christian and a non-Christian. The debate this week was on the moral argument, which argues that meaningful morality, including free will, human rights, moral rules, moral obligations, and moral significance, must be grounded in God.
THIS IS A MUST-LISTEN.
The debate starts a bit into the podcast, after they review audience reactions to last week and preview the next week’s topic.
Here is the link to the podcast. (MP3 audio)
If you have trouble with that link, try here instead.
The atheist Paul Orton argues this:
- no moral absolutes
- morality is a set evolved conventions
- the set varies by time and place
The Christian David Robertson argues this:
- morality is meaningless unless there are moral absolutes
- cultural relativism doesn’t rationally ground moral judgments
- the Bible does not teach that slavery is good
One of the best parts of the debate is when David contrasts H.G. Wells, an atheistic socialist who embraced socialism and fascism as a natural extension of his atheism, and a Christian, William Wilberforce who spent over two decades of his life trying to free the slaves in the UK.
This debate can be seen as an illustration of the thesis that I advanced in my series of posts on atheism and morality, in which I argued that atheism does not ground the minimal requirements for rational morality.
This page contains a link to an excellent lecture on the ontological foundations of rational morality, as well as a number of debates between Christians and atheists on whether morality is rationally grounded by the worldview of atheism. And you can find some other apologetics posts here, including an article on whether the the moral statements of atheists are even intelligible, on atheism.
The best book ever written on this topic is Greg Koukl and Francis J. Beckwith’s “Relativism: Feet Firmly Planted in Mid-Air“. You can see Greg deliver a lecture about relativism to an audience of students and faculty at UCLA (MP3 audio here). If you want to read something free on the web that explains the problems with moral relativism, which is the view of morality that is grounded by atheism, look here.
One thought on “Debate: Must morality be grounded by God?”